Blog

How do you build an us vs them ad? A row-by-row structure for Meta.

A row builder where every line has the customer's words, the proof you hold, and a source for the factor.

Every row needs proof you already hold. Three real LED mask ads that set it against creams and earlier masks, on ink.

An us vs them ad is easy to lay out and easy to get wrong. The layout is two columns and a few rows. The hard part is the second column: the usual alternative, described so a shopper can check it.

So this post works to one rule. Every row needs proof you already hold, and "them" is a category or the old way of solving the problem, not a named rival. You'll get two tables: a row builder with a column for that proof, and Meta's specs for the static and the video version.

What is an us vs them ad?

Short answer

An us vs them ad sets your product beside the usual alternative, one buying factor per row, so the viewer reads the difference at a glance. Every row needs proof you already hold: a spec, a policy, a count from your own reviews. A row you can't prove comes out.

That definition and the proof rule are CreatStrat's framing, not Meta's and not a research finding.

The format puts two options side by side, judged on the same factors at one moment. Researchers study the wider family as comparative advertising, and the findings cut both ways.

According to a 1997 meta-analysis in the Journal of Marketing (Grewal and colleagues), comparative ads were more effective than noncomparative ads in generating attention, message and brand awareness, levels of message processing, favorable sponsored brand attitudes, and increased purchase intentions and behaviors; however, they evoked lower source believability and a less favorable attitude toward the ad.

The analysis was published in 1997, before social feeds. It doesn't measure Meta delivery, click-through rate, cost per acquisition or return on ad spend.

Our reading, not the study's: a format that evokes lower source believability is a reason to put proof in every row.

What goes in each row of an us vs them ad?

Each row of an us vs them ad holds five things: the buying factor in the customer's words, what your product does, what the usual alternative does, the proof you hold for the line, and where the factor came from.

The builder is CreatStrat's framework. The example is illustrative: GOOD COMPANY is a fictional brand, and its refill hand-soap tablets were invented for this post. The review method comes from our reviews post; the proof column and the row order are our judgement.

The columns, left to right:

  1. Row: numbered in count order, strongest first. Our judgement.
  2. Buying factor in the customer's words: the line as customers wrote it in reviews, support tickets or return notes. The method, tag each line by need, then count, is from our reviews post. Adding return reasons and pre-purchase questions is our addition, not something that post says.
  3. Your product: one short line, a fact about the product. Our judgement.
  4. The usual alternative: a category or the old way ("doing it by hand"), described by something a shopper can check on a shelf or a product page. Category over named brand is this post's default; describing it fairly is judgement.
  5. Proof you hold: the document behind your product's cell (a spec sheet, package dimensions, a published policy, a count from your own reviews), plus a dated shelf or price check for the alternative's cell. The list is our judgement. The standard, to check every specific claim against a named source, is section 8 of our brief post.
  6. Where the factor came from: a review (with its star band), an objection (a support or pre-purchase question), or a return reason. Our judgement, extending the reviews post.
The us vs them row builder, filled in for a fictional brand (illustrative)
RowBuying factor (customer's words)GOOD COMPANYSupermarket pump-bottle hand soapProof you holdWhere the factor came from
1"Throwing out a plastic bottle every month"One glass bottle, refilled from a tabletA new plastic pump bottle each timeSpec sheet: bottle material, refill format. Dated shelf check for this column5-star reviews, the most-tagged need
2"Spare bottles taking over the cabinet"A month of refills fits in one envelopeA full-size bottle for every refillPackage dimensions. Dated shelf photo for this column2 to 4 star reviews
3"Pumps that break in a week"Metal pump, replaced free if it breaksPlastic pump, sold only with a full bottleYour published replacement policy. Dated shelf check for this columnReturn reasons
Cut"What does a refill cost per wash?"Cut this rowYou hold your own price but no dated shelf price for this column, so the row is outPre-purchase question

The fourth row came out because a price row needs a dated price for both columns, and you hold only one: your own. Without a dated shelf price for the supermarket bottle, the cost-per-wash line has nothing behind it. That's the proof rule applied to a real cell.

If you'd like to see a finished static built from your product page before you fill these rows yourself, the free ad comes with its brief and Meta copy.

Get my free ad →

Free. One finished static ad with its brief and Meta copy, emailed within 24 hours. One per brand.

Who is "them" in an us vs them ad?

For the them column, use a category or the old way of solving the problem, described by something a shopper can check on a shelf or a product page. That's our default, not a research finding.

The reason is the proof test. A category sits on a shelf, so you can hold a dated check of it, and every cell in that column can be backed. Apply the same test to anything else you'd put in that column: a cell with no dated document behind it comes out.

Then describe the alternative the way its own buyer would: a full bottle with its own pump, on the supermarket shelf, rather than "wasteful". If a fair description removes the row, the row was weak (our judgement).

The them column
A them a shopper can check.
Two versions of the same column for a luggage brand. Each line on the right can be checked on a product page.
Can’t check
The usual alternative

Other luggage: chaotic

Other bags: not as smart

Other brands: forgettable

No document backs these lines. The rows come out.

Can check
The usual alternative

Packing loose: one open compartment

A suitcase with no built-in dividers

Shirts and chargers in the same space

Each line can be checked, and dated.

Illustrative example. WAYPOINT is a fictional brand and these lines were written for this example.

Put your brand mark and product on the us column header. In Pechmann and Stewart's 1990 study in the Journal of Consumer Research, direct comparative claims increased awareness of competitors and sponsor misidentifications for established brands: viewers named the wrong sponsor. It isn't a Meta study. The layout rule we take from it is our judgement: the mark sits on your column, so nobody has to guess whose ad it is.

Where do the buying factors come from?

Take the buying factors from customer language you already hold: review lines, pre-purchase questions and return reasons, tagged by need and then counted.

Our reviews post sets which reviews to read first: 2 to 4 star reviews for trade-offs, 1-star reviews for objections, 5-star reviews for the customer's own vocabulary. Tag each line by need, not keyword, then count. Competitor reviews are research, not ad copy, and that post says so. Return reasons and pre-purchase questions are our addition, not that post's.

A strong factor can sit unused in reviews a brand already has:

The first thing CreatStrat found was an angle we'd never advertised despite it appearing repeatedly in our customer reviews. They turned it into several concepts, we launched them, and two became some of our strongest ads. That paid for the subscription many times over.

Daniel W. · CreatStrat customer

Your rows come from the same place: what customers already wrote.

The count orders the rows. Our rule for row 1: the most-tagged need where you hold proof and the alternative visibly differs. The reviews post also warns that counting finds the angle you already run, so read the bottom of the list on purpose. A lower-count need can be row 3.

How many rows fit in a 4:5 static, and where does the eye go?

Meta's Ads Guide lists a 4:5 ratio and a resolution of 1440 x 1800 pixels for Facebook Feed image ads (Meta Ads Guide, "Awareness Image Ad Specs on Facebook Feed", accessed November 2, 2026).

Three to five rows fit, by our judgement. A header row (your brand mark against "the usual way") plus three to five rows leaves room for a hook line and the product shot. Six rows force the type small enough that it stops reading in a thumb-scroll. We found no sourced test of how many rows work best.

With more than five factors, split them across two statics, each led by a different strongest factor, or use a carousel with one factor per card. A new first row is a new idea. A recolor is the same idea (what makes two concepts different).

For the eye path, our judgement: strongest factor in row 1, and your column on the side the viewer reads first (left in left-to-right languages) or highlighted. We found no sourced eye-tracking study on comparison tables in feed ads. Where the hook line, product, proof and brand mark go is in the zone map for a static; the text around the image is in the copy fields outside the image.

How do you make a video version?

Turn each row into one beat: the factor on screen as text or voiceover first, then the two sides shown. That structure is ours.

Use as many beats as the static has rows, three to five. We found no sourced timing per beat, so this post gives no seconds.

Rows to beats
Each row becomes one beat.
The three kept rows from the builder, in order. The factor shows as text or voiceover first, then both sides.
  1. 01Row 1: Throwing out a plastic bottle every month Opens the video

    The factor on screen, then a plastic pump bottle going in the bin beside one glass bottle refilled from a tablet.

  2. 02Row 2: Spare bottles taking over the cabinet

    A shelf of full-size bottles, then a month of refills in one envelope.

  3. 03Row 3: Pumps that break in a week

    A pump bottle sold whole, then the metal pump with the replacement policy on screen.

Illustrative example. GOOD COMPANY is a fictional brand and these beats were written for this example. No timing is shown because we found no sourced timing per beat.

There are two ways to shoot it. A split-screen puts both sides in one frame: left and right in a 4:5 video, top and bottom in a 9:16 one. A side-by-side demonstration does the same task both ways, in one frame or in back-to-back cuts.

Cut your side from footage you already own, the way a mashup ad is built. Show the them side as the category, unbranded.

Meta lists "Video Captions: Optional, but recommended" on both video pages (Meta Ads Guide, "Awareness Video Ad Specs on Facebook Feed" and "Awareness Video Ad Specs on Instagram Reels", accessed November 2, 2026). The factor text should be on screen anyway, in our view.

For Reels, Meta's Ads Guide page "Awareness Video Ad Specs on Instagram Reels" (accessed November 2, 2026) says: "Consider leaving at least 14% of the top, 35% of the bottom, and 6% on each side of your asset free from text, logos, or other important creative elements." Our arithmetic from Meta's percentages, not Meta guidance: that leaves a usable band 51% of the frame tall and 88% wide. In a 9:16 top-and-bottom split, divide that band rather than the full frame. Each side gets about a quarter of the frame height, with the divider near 40% from the top (14 plus 25.5). The rest is in the full Reels frame map.

Meta's specs for the static and the video version (Meta Ads Guide, accessed November 2, 2026)
VersionPlacementRatioResolutionWhat the page says about text, captions and soundMeta page
Static imageFacebook Feed4:51440 x 1800 pixelsThe page checked doesn't list text-on-image guidanceMeta Ads Guide, "Awareness Image Ad Specs on Facebook Feed" [1]
VideoFacebook Feed4:51440 x 1800 pixels"Video Captions: Optional, but recommended"; "Video Sound: Optional, but recommended""Awareness Video Ad Specs on Facebook Feed" [2]
VideoInstagram Reels9:161440 x 2560 pixels"Consider leaving at least 14% of the top, 35% of the bottom, and 6% on each side of your asset free from text, logos, or other important creative elements."; "Video Captions: Optional, but recommended"; "Video Sound: Optional, but strongly recommended""Awareness Video Ad Specs on Instagram Reels" [3]

To read the video's results, start with which part of your ad each metric points to.

How CreatStrat handles statics

Statics are one of the formats in the weekly mix. CreatStrat is a software subscription that delivers finished ads every week; CreatStrat researches, plans the tests, writes the brief, and produces the finished statics, carousels, mashups, AI video, and AI UGC, each with its Meta copy; your creative strategist is built in.

Each finished ad arrives with its brief, which names the customer avatar, the angle and the hook, and with its Meta copy. CreatStrat produces the finished ads; you launch them in your own Meta account.

Plans are $299, $499, or $899 a month for 5, 10, or 20 ads a week, one combined monthly price, billed monthly, cancel anytime. Choose your ad mix, or read what a weekly plan delivers.

Frequently asked questions

What is an us vs them ad? An us vs them ad sets your product beside the usual alternative, one buying factor per row, so the viewer reads the difference at a glance. Each row needs proof you hold, such as a spec, a policy, or a count from your own reviews.

How many rows should an us vs them ad have? Three to five for a 4:5 static, by our judgement. We found no sourced test of how many rows work best. If you have more than five factors, split them across two statics or use a carousel.

Which buying factor should go first? The one your customers raise most often, among the factors where you hold proof and the alternative visibly differs. That's our judgement, not a tested rule. Put it in row 1, and put your column where the viewer reads first.

What counts as proof for a row? A document you already hold: a spec sheet, package dimensions, a published policy, or a count from your own reviews. For the alternative's column, a dated check of a shelf or product page. If a cell has no document behind it, cut the row.

Should you make a static or a video version first? Build the static first: it's the same rows without footage to cut, and each row later becomes one beat of the video. That's our judgement; we found no sourced comparison of the two for this format.

What's the difference between an us vs them ad and a before-and-after ad? An us vs them ad compares two options on the same factors at one moment. A before-and-after ad compares one state with a later state over time.

Fill row 1 from your own reviews

Start with row 1: the factor your customers raise most, and the proof you hold for it. Share a product page URL and email. Within 24 hours we'll send a finished static ad for your product, with its brief and Meta copy. One per brand.

Get my free ad →

Want to see the app first? Book a demo →

Sources

  1. Meta. Awareness Image Ad Specs on Facebook Feed. Meta Ads Guide. https://www.facebook.com/business/ads-guide/update/image/facebook-feed. Accessed November 2, 2026.
  2. Meta. Awareness Video Ad Specs on Facebook Feed. Meta Ads Guide. https://www.facebook.com/business/ads-guide/update/video/facebook-feed. Accessed November 2, 2026.
  3. Meta. Awareness Video Ad Specs on Instagram Reels. Meta Ads Guide. https://www.facebook.com/business/ads-guide/update/video/instagram-reels. Accessed November 2, 2026.
  4. Grewal, D., Kavanoor, S., Fern, E. F., Costley, C., & Barnes, J. (1997). Comparative versus noncomparative advertising: A meta-analysis. Journal of Marketing, 61(4), 1-15. doi:10.1177/002224299706100401.
  5. Pechmann, C., & Stewart, D. W. (1990). The effects of comparative advertising on attention, memory, and purchase intentions. Journal of Consumer Research, 17(2), 180-191. doi:10.1086/208548.
Free static ad

Your product. Your first ad. Free.

Share a product page URL and email. Within 24 hours we’ll send a finished static ad for your product, with its brief and Meta copy. One per brand.